God can read hearts--but we don't read God's heart very well.
The great horror that many feel when they read the OT is the blood and gore of it all.
The God that Jesus showed us was not that kind of God.
The God who "so loved the world that he gave his only be-gotten son" yielded that son to a world that so despised the gift that they killed Jesus.
Is it relevant to say that God did not kill his own child? He gave his son and both he and Jesus knew what would happen--but is that the same as killing him? If I gave myself as a hostage to save my brother, knowing the captors would kill me would my father be a murderer?
Is it too fine a point to make that Abraham was to learn and to demonstrate for us that giving his own hopes and his own beloved to God could only be grasped through this experience?
It is also important to me that the word burnt offering had no blood associated with it.
We are to be "holy living sacrifice" as Romans says. We do not kill nor do we kill ourselves --but we live wholey for God.
Are we humans able to grasp the length and heigth and breadth of God's love without a living example of it?
What words existed at the time to tell Abraham how much trust it would take to follow God's purpose?
What example was there to show us now the wrenching "born-again" in a death? Really we can't communicate it.
I can only say as others have: God is Love , He neither explicitly commanded a killing nor did he permit it.
If Jesus is the one to show us what God is like then let us see that even at death he did not say "Why did you kill me?" but "into your hand I give my spirit."
Is the test for any of us more this: can we trust God with our life? Is he the killer God of caprice and double -tongued trickery?
Bottom line on the Genesis story: If Abraham refused to use the word "sacrifice" in his story and only used the word "burnt offering", why not honor him and God by the distinction.
Or do we just prefer to think of God as an arbitrary SOB who tells us he is one thing, can run contrary to it and call it good anyway.
What real benefit is there believing that God always was able to make his thoughts clear to us? Jesus had to come to make it clear who his father really is and we still love to think of God as slightly monstrous?
God tempered the faith of Abraham and through the trial reassured Abraham and Us that he is trustworthy and his ways are truly higher than ours. If all we want to see is a very linear and crude test of obedience that requires God to suspend his own laws----what is wrong with us? The words allow for a different story.
I won't tell it anyother way.